Who will President Obama nominate to replace Justice Antonin Scalia

Despite a constitutional mandate to do so, senate majority leader Mitch McConnell has decreed that the Republicans will not conduct any hearings to consider whether to approve anyone whom President Obama might nominate to replace recently deceased Justice Antonin Scalia.

So much for the importance of his oath to uphold the Constitution and the laws of the United States.

President Obama has announced that he will nominate someone in “due time.” Speculation abounds.

The identity of the person he nominates is less clear than the strategy he uses to select his nominee. Not only must he select someone above reproach, he must select someone who has recently been approved by the senate to serve in a judicial or law enforcement position. The nominee must be so above reproach and non-controversial as to cast shame onto anyone who opposes him or her. That would be shame of the sort that would result in the senator’s loss in a November reelection bid. Given the right candidate, the democrats could regain control of the Senate.

One such candidate is Judge Sri Srinivasan, whom the senate unanimously confirmed by a vote of 97-0 in May 2013 to serve on the United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. In addition to serving as a judge on the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, he served as a deputy solicitor general in DOJ’s Office of the Solicitor General. As a south asian minority (born in India) with a JD and an MBA from Stanford, his credentials are difficult to beat.

Another difficult to beat contender is Attorney General Loretta Lynch, whom the Senate recently confirmed. Tom Goldstein, who runs the influential SCOTUSblog, believes she will be the nominee. NBC News reports,

But tapping Lynch to fill the seat of Scalia, who died suddenly Saturday, poses a perception problem for Republicans because her “history as a career prosecutor makes it very difficult to paint her as excessively liberal,” Goldstein wrote.

Lynch would be the first black woman ever nominated to the nation’s highest court — and the GOP would have a political problem during an election year if the Republicans refused to even consider her nomination, Goldstein wrote.

“I think the administration would relish the prospect of Republicans either refusing to give Lynch a vote or seeming to treat her unfairly in the confirmation process,” Goldstein wrote. “Either eventuality would motivate both black and women voters.”

Stay tuned as President Obama’s choice may turn out to be the most important and consequential decision he makes during his presidency. It really is that important. In addition to losing control of the senate, a republican refusal to consider her could cost the republicans the fall election.

20 Responses to Who will President Obama nominate to replace Justice Antonin Scalia

  1. roderick2012 says:

    All Obama has to do is nominate someone and watch the Republicans play defense and explain why they won’t even give Obama’s nominee a hearing for the next nine months.

  2. gblock says:

    I heard on NPR that a couple of Republicans in key positions who at first said they would not make a move to confirm a successor to Justice Scalia are now saying well, let’s see who President Obama nominates.

  3. oldgold says:

    Is Harriet Miers still among the living?

  4. Trained Observer says:

    Hoping he nominates Loretta Lynch.

    • bettykath says:

      He’s got at least a couple of great choices that the Republicans should be willing to confirm if they would drop their partisan b.s.

      Loretta Lynch and Sri Srinivasan are two of them.

    • roderick2012 says:

      No she’s too old and from a recent pic too uh chubby.

      He already nominated a Latina with Type I diabetes.

      Obama needs to nominate someone who is HEALTHY and no older than his/her late 40’s early 50’s.

  5. Two sides to a story says:

    This could be the most interesting checkmate on the Republican party ever!

  6. Disappointed says:

    The GOP has made it clear they are the party of moochers. They want a pay check but they refuse to work for it. I’m over them. Will never vote republican, EVER!!

    • I hear you. At the rate they are going, they may soon cease to be a party.

      From Robert Reich: The Death of the Republican Party

      • Malisha says:

        But just as you cannot put a corporation in prison for committing illegal acts, you cannot sentence a political party to death for murdering the Constitution or for terroristic threatening aimed at our fragile democracy. So they will live on, the real zombie monsters among us. This probably explains our media’s love affair with the zombie meme. WE’RE LIVING IT!!! HELP!!!

      • bettykath says:

        The party was taken over by the tea partiers. If they are sufficiently fractured, a well organized left leaning party might very well take them over. By left leaning, I mean a party well left of the Democrats who have moved to right of center. Bernie may be bringing them back left though. If he can also break their ties to the corporations, taking over the Repubs won’t be necessary. Think there might be influx to the Dems of moderate conservatives disgusted with their “party”? That would keep the Dems right of center regardless of Bernie. We’re living in an historical period where the possible answers are many.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: