Friday, February 21, 2014
Good morning:
Frances Robles of The New York Times reported yesterday that New York City has settled a wrongful conviction claim for $6.4 million by David Ranta, an innocent man who was framed for a murder by a rogue Brooklyn detective named Louis Scarcella. Ranta served 23 years in prison and suffered a heart attack the day after he was released from prison. Fortunately, he survived the heart attack.
The crime occurred in 1990. The victim was Chaskell Werzberger, a Hassidic rabbi and Holocaust survivor who was shot in the head as he got into his car by a person who had robbed a jewelry store across the street. The robber stole his car and used it as a getaway vehicle.
The unsolved murder upset the Orthodox Jewish community that had overwhelmingly voted for the newly elected District Attorney, Charles J. Hynes. He felt pressured to solve the crime and convict the perpetrator.
Ranta was convicted by eyewitness testimony and a confession that he denied making.
Many years after the conviction, one eyewitness admitted that Detective Scarcella told him which photograph to select in a photo spread. Two other witnesses subsequently admitted they had lied in exchange for leniency in matters pending against them.
A reinvestigation of the case by the Conviction Integrity Unit of the D.A.’s office resulted in the discovery that Detective Scarcella had investigated a suspect named Joseph Astin, who was identified as the killer by an anonymous caller. However, he stopped investigating Astin after Astin died in a traffic accident and he did not submit any paperwork documenting his efforts.
Astin’s widow later claimed that Astin had committed the murder, but efforts to free Ranta were unsuccessful.
Ranta’s wrongful conviction is not the only case in which now retired Detective Scarcella used false confessions and coached witnesses to lie in order to obtain a conviction.
Kenneth P. Thompson, the new Brooklyn District Attorney who defeated Charles J. Hines last November in a landslide election due in no small part to citizen outrage about the way he mishandled wrongful-conviction complaints about Scarcella, has convened a three-person panel to review dozens of his cases.
Ranta is still planning to sue the State of New York.
Yesterday, the Florida legislature advanced plans to expand its “Shoot First” law with a warning shot bill. HB 89 is a misguided and perverse response to the Marissa Alexander case. It would give shooters the power to show a gun and fire a warning shot while avoiding prison time but fails to actually address any of the underlying problems with the law itself, allowing further leeway to those who would seek vigilante justice.
Florida’s behavior is irresponsible and a slap in the face less a week after the Micheal Dunn trial verdict. Tell officials #BlackLivesMatter and help us put an end to “Shoot First” laws nationwide once and for all: http://act.colorofchange.org/sign/JordanDavis/.
Corruption seem to be rampant in our police departments. I also believe corruption played a role in the Trayvon martin case
OT…. I know everyone here is pretty damn savvy but thought I should pass this along anyway…. My Dad got a call this morning from 415-251-3851…. When I checked it out I got this info.
Victims are told they owe money to the IRS and it must be paid promptly through a pre-loaded debit card or wire transfer. If the victim refuses to cooperate, they are then threatened with arrest, deportation or suspension of a business or driver’s license. In many cases, the caller becomes hostile and insulting.
This article from the http://www.irs.gov website tells you how to report these scams:
Thank you very much. I will also begin putting scammer numbers here, so everyone can see. They seem to come in waves. I always report them, and, I never answer, except for a while there, the numbers had Washington state area codes, and I was worried that family may be calling.
Lately, the area codes have been- New Jersey and Ohio, I think.
Always good to get the word out to as many people as possible, so thank you!
My pleasure… I’ve been getting a lot of Virginia calls in the last few weeks. The Do Not Call List isn’t worth the effort any more, although I keep reporting. We get somewhere between 6-8 local calls from construction/solar/lower energy & heating etc. companies daily…
Wow. But that IRS thing? That’s creepy. Harassment….
Fraud actually… Impersonating a federal employee
18 U.S. Code § 912 – Officer or employee of the United States
Oh, okay. Well, that makes total sense. So it is important to get the word out.
And Hynes is a horrible criminal. He is a liar and a perjuror and a pedophile-support-team member and a vicious sonofabitch.
Malisha, Do you dislike this man? Your comment seems somewhat ambiguous. 🙂
Because I have history with Hynes. He protected a pedophile who took custody of his molested daughter away from her protective mother, and who then mistreated and molested the child so seriously that she became dangerously anorexic by the age of 9 so that she had to be hospitalized and put on an IV in order to save her life. The mother, for taking her to the hospital where they were forced to keep her in critical care for 11 days (she had to gain enough weight not to die before she could leave the critical care unit) was punished by a no-contact order. The girl got totally and horribly brain-washed by the conduct of her molester father (a physician for the Veterans Administration), Hynes, a judge in the NY Supreme Court (who actually met with her personally to assure her that her father, and not her mother, had saved her life because her mother was “narcissistic and mentally ill”), and several corrupt NY City officials who faked everything that needed to be faked to frustrate a NY Legislative investigation into the corruption that Hynes had set in place to keep this mother and child apart. The girl grew up to be a dangerous lunatic who threatens suicide to force everyone to do her bidding and who forbad her mother from coming to her wedding. She married into a family run by similar bullies, one of whom is very big in the American Enterprise Institute. They are among the most dangerous and thuggish people our country has to offer. Hynes is high in their hierarchy. He has notches all over his gun. They should all be in cells near that of FoDung. Hynes should be in the smallest.
SO! Frances Robles, who started the completely false rumor that RTL had been plagued by crime (“including one other shooting”) in the year before Fogen “had to kill” Trayvon Martin, and who, when informed of it NOT only did nothing to correct the misinformation (that had been repeated over a thousand times in two weeks and that had eventually contributed to the official blessing of the murderer “protecting his turf”) but pretended to be interested in the proof (result of a FOIA) and then just stopped talking and said simply, “I’m not with the MIAMI HERALD any more” —
IS NOW A VERY IMPORTANT AND HIGHLY RESPECTED REPORTER FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES.
SHAME ON HER!!
SHAME SHAME SHAME SHAME SHAME!!!
❗ ❗ ❗ ❗ ❗ ❗ :angry:
I am sure she’s taking Judith Miller’s desk, you know the one who was the stenographer for the GW Bush White House and repeated all of that false information about Iraq’s WMDs?
Complete and total SHAME in lights on TIMES SQUARE!
Rogue cops like Scarcella and rogue forensic analysts like Fred Zain in West Virginia do incalculable damage to the innocent people they convict.
Sometimes that damage includes an execution.
The damage they cause to the legitimacy of the criminal justice system also is incalculable.
This certainly speaks to the discussion of a few days ago on this site about the validity of crime statistics, doesn’t it? Police and others involved in the criminal justice system are so eager to close cases that they sometimes do it by any means necessary. Which then leaves the real perps on the street to get bolder and bolder. And everybody suffers.
The worst part is that they get to go to work everyday with that agenda and repeat it for years and mots don’t get caught.
In Camden NJ there were near a hundred convictions overturned recently as several cops played the same games. They planted drugs, refused most accused blood & urine tests to prove innocence. They were finally caught, fired arrested and charged but look at all the destroyed lives.
And when they ARE caught nothing is done to remedy the problem other than the taxpayers paying off the surviving victims if there has been a successful ten-or-more-year struggle to re-establish some kind of return to normal. NEVER a remedy other than pay-off.
Would a rogue cop or forensic get the death penalty for their efforts towards conviction resulting in the execution of an innocent person? Their actions / false testimony resulted in wrongful death(s).
Scarcella should spend the rest of his miserable lying life in prison for this.
I agree.
Cases like this make my blood boil. Rogue cops and detectives are no different from the criminals who got away.