Wednesday, January 8, 2014
Closing arguments will resume today in the Kelly Thomas case with the case expected to go the jury by the end of the day.
Defense attorney John Barnett, who represents Manuel Ramos, will complete his final argument this morning. He spoke for about 90 minutes yesterday afternoon but did not complete his final argument before Judge William Froeberg recessed the trial for the day. After he finishes his argument today, defense attorney Michael Schwartz will give his closing argument on behalf of his client, Jay Cicinelli.
Orange County District Attorney Anthony Rackauckas completed his opening closing argument yesterday afternoon and will have an opportunity to rebut the arguments of defense counsel after Schwartz concludes his argument.
You can watch closing arguments via livestream right here, beginning at approximately 9 am PST.
You can review the arguments of counsel yesterday by going here.
Briefly, police responded to a 911 call reporting a suspicious person attempting to break into vehicles parked at the Fullerton Transportation Center. Defendant Manuel Ramos was the first officer to arrive. He encountered Kelly Thomas, a mentally ill homeless person he knew from previous encounters. After a brief conversation, Ramos put on plastic gloves and told him he was going to fuck him up. Thomas stood up and attempted to get away, but Ramos and another officer got him down on the ground and began beating him. Other officers arrived and the beating continued until Thomas lost consciousness. Ramos hit him with his baton and Cicinelli hit him multiple times in the face with his taser.
The incident was captured on videotape by a security camera and audio from body microphones worn by police officers. The prosecution spliced the audio and video together to create an exhibit that has served as the centerpiece of the trial.
The prosecution has presented expert testimony that Thomas died as a result of the beating. The defense has presented expert testimony that he died as the result of an enlarged heart weakened by methamphetamine use.
You can read my article yesterday summarizing the case here.
The final words of a 37-year-old homeless man filled the packed Orange County courtroom.
“Dad help me.”
“God help me.”
“Help me. Help me. Help me.”
Orange County Dist. Atty. Tony Rackauckas let Kelly Thomas’ voice provide an emotional undertone to his closing arguments Tuesday in a widely watched criminal case against a pair of Fullerton police officers accused of killing the homeless man in a furious beating on a summer night in 2011.
“I don’t know about you,” Rackauckas told jurors, “but I can’t recall ever hearing such pleas. Such crying. Such begging for his life. Ever.”
Manuel Ramos is charged with second degree murder and involuntary manslaughter. Jay Cicinelli is charged with involuntary manslaughter and use of excessive force.
Writing articles and maintaining this blog involves a lot of time and effort. This is our 840th post in a little over two years. Please consider making a donation today, if you value what we do and would like us to continue producing articles for your information and enjoyment.