Tuesday, March 26, 2013
Now that W8 (Dee Dee) has apparently admitted during the defense deposition on March 13th that she lied when she told Benjamin Crump during a telephone interview and later confirmed to BDLR that she did not go to Trayvon Martin’s funeral because she was sick and went to a hospital, the inevitable question is:
How might this affect the trial?
First, do not expect to see her charged with perjury because BDLR’s question was ambiguous (i.e., went to a hospital or someplace) and her answer was not material (i.e., important enough to affect the outcome of the trial).
Second, let’s take a look at how this admission might come out at trial.
BDLR would ask her if she attended the wake or the funeral and she would answer, “No.”
BDLR would then ask her why not and she probably would answer that she was too upset and could not handle it.
Assuming for the sake of argument that the prosecution either did not move in limine (i.e., before the trial begins) to prohibit the defense from pursuing this line of inquiry pursuant to Rule 608(b) or if it did, Judge Nelson denied the motion, BDLR would have the option to end that line of inquiry (i.e., permitting the defense to bring it out on cross) or to proceed further and reveal her lie).
Any experienced prosecutor, and BDLR is experienced, would elect to reveal her lie in the least damaging manner possible rather than allow the defense to bring it out on cross in the most damaging manner possible.
This is how it might work:
BDLR: Do you recall Benjamin Crump interviewing you by phone in March of last year regarding your cell phone conversations with Trayvon before the shooting?
BDLR: Do you recall him asking you, if you went to Trayvon’s wake and funeral?
BDLR: What, if anything did you tell him?
DD: I told him that I did not go to either one.
BDLR: Was that truth?
BDLR: Did he ask why you did not go the funeral and the wake?
BDLR: What did you tell him?
DD: I told him I was sick and went to the hospital.
BDLR: Was that the truth?
BDLR: What was the truth?
DD: I was too upset and could not handle it.
BDLR: Why didn’t you tell him that?
DD: I did not want to admit to his mother that I was not strong enough to be there for her.
BDLR: Are you referring to Sybrina Fulton?
BDLR: Was Trayvon’s mother present when Mr. Crump interviewed you?
DD: Yes, she was in Mr. Crump’s office listening over the speaker phone.
BDLR: How did you know that?
DD: Mr. Crump introduced her and she said, “Hello.”
BDLR: Did there come a later time when I interviewed you in person?
BDLR: Do you recall when that was?
DD: I think it was about a month later.
BDLR: Was Trayvon’s mother present when I interviewed you?
DD: Yes, she gave me a ride to the office where you interviewed me and she sat next to me the whole time.
BDLR: Did you swear to tell the truth and nothing but the truth during the interview?
BDLR: Did I ask you if you went to the funeral and the wake?
BDLR: What did you say?
DD: I lied and told you that my blood pressure was very high and I went to the hospital instead.
BDLR: Do you suffer from high blood pressure?
BDLR: Why did you lie to me?
DD: I did not want to admit to Trayvon’s mother that I could not deal with what happened to Trayvon. I could not handle seeing him dead or in a casket, so I lied to her and to Mr. Crump.
BDLR: Are you sorry that you lied?
BDLR: Have you apologized to Trayvon’s mom and dad.
BDLR: Did you love Trayvon?
DD: Yes, I still do.
BDLR: Do you miss him?
DD: Yes, very much.
BDLR: Thank you. Your witness, counsel.
Picture this scene taking place before a jury in a crowded courtroom in June with a nation and the world looking on, after the prosecution has introduced all of its damning evidence against the defendant, including the medical examiner’s testimony using graphic color photos taken during the autopsy, as this young woman confesses her love and affection for Trayvon while baring her soul and tearfully confessing to her overwhelming sense of loss, responsibility, confusion, weakness and guilt.
If BDLR conducts the direct examination properly, as I believe he will, the best cross will be no cross. The jury will not take kindly to a defense attorney picking on her and prolonging her agony.
Finally, do not forget that the phone records and the other evidence in the case will independently confirm everything else she says about her conversation with Trayvon.
One understandable simple lie by Dee Dee is relatively unimportant compared to the vast ocean of lies uttered by the defendant in this case.
Is the prosecution crumbling? I don’t think so.
Writing articles every day and maintaining the integrity and safety of this site from people who would like nothing better than to silence us forever is a tough job requiring many hours of work. If you like this site, please consider making a secure donation via Paypal by clicking the yellow donation button in the upper right corner just below the search box.
Your donations are appreciated